Guide

Brad Feld and Jason Mendelson's framing in Venture Deals still holds: almost every fight is about economics (who gets the money) or control (who decides). Everything else is secondary until those are right.

Founders often over-rotate on valuation and under-rotate on board seats, preference structure, and pool size. Investors sometimes do the reverse in hot markets — concede price, tighten control. Read both columns.

The big idea

A restaurant partnership is the picture. Economics is how you split the night's till. Control is who can fire the chef, take on debt, or sell the building. The analogy breaks because preferred stock can hold vetoes even when founders own a majority of the fully diluted table.

Economic terms

TermWhat it setsDeep dive
Valuation / pricePre-money, share price, ownershipPriced rounds, valuation
Option poolSize and whether it sits pre-moneyOption pools
Liquidation preferenceWho gets paid first in an exitLiquidation preferences
Anti-dilutionProtection in a down roundAnti-dilution
DividendsUsually non-cumulative, immaterial early—
Participation / pro-rataRight to maintain ownership in future roundsPro-rata rights

Control terms

TermWhat it setsDeep dive
Board compositionWho sits in the boardroomBoard seats
Protective provisionsInvestor veto listProtective provisions
Drag-along / vote agreementsAbility to force a saleDrag-along and tag-along
Information rightsWhat reporting investors getControl terms
ROFR / co-saleLimits on transferring founder sharesROFR and co-sale

You do not negotiate every sentence equally. You negotiate the blanks that move ownership, cash-on-exit, and who can fire the CEO.

A typical Series A sheet walks offering terms (amount, pre-money, pool %), charter terms (prefs, voting, anti-dilution), stock-purchase themes, investor rights, board and voting, founder vesting, then no-shop and fees. Build a pro forma cap table from the offering block before you celebrate.

Common mistakes

  • Winning valuation and losing the board. Control is harder to unwind than price.
  • Skipping pool size. A bloated pre-money pool is a stealth price cut.
  • Treating dividends and redemption as noise without reading them. Early-stage they should be boring; if they are not, stop.

Check yourself

An investor concedes 5% more dilution but takes a board majority and participating preferred. Did you "win"?

Usually no. You sold control and exit economics for a headline.

Where do you look first on a sheet besides the pre-money number?

Pool size, liquidation preference, anti-dilution, and board composition.

Key takeaways

  • Split the sheet into economics and control. Negotiate both.
  • Valuation is one economic cell. Pool, prefs, and anti-dilution rewrite it.
  • If you must concede, prefer dilution over giving away the board.

Further learning

Next, binding terms — what actually locks before close.